Yeah… weird.

So, did anyone watch Idol Gives Back last night? Did you happen to notice that they chose to close out the show with a (modified) version of “Shout to the Lord” by Darlene Zschech?

Were you as confused as we were? Weird.


21 thoughts on “Yeah… weird.

  1. I’m not sure that’s actually the video of the performance. YouTube is blocked here at work, so I just grabbed the url from a Google search.

    Can someone let me know?

  2. weird? that’s the word you choose for this situation?

    how about censored?

    or sanitized?

    or worthless?

    or mockery?

    or why bother at all?

  3. The Stiller bit at the very end was in poor taste. Even apart from it happening on the heels of “Shout to the Lord.” It soiled the whole vibe of the evening for me.

    I don’t think I was as personally offended by their use of the “Shout to the Lord” as you were. 😆

    I can get with the “why bother” point however. I mean, if you’re going to yank Jesus’ name from the tune, it certainly isn’t going to resonate as well with those most familiar with the song.

    And what the heck does that song even mean to someone who isn’t prone to “worshiping” the savior, shepherd, king, Lord?

    I was more confused by their choice of song than anything else.

    There is a definite “Jesus vibe” to this season however. Several performers have sung songs which mention, or communicate with, Jesus – and by name. Dolly Parton turned her performance into a revival meeting. Mariah Carey dropped the J-bomb during her performance as well. It even goes all the way back to when they used the Robbie Seay Band’s song for the early promos.

    I suspect they see a way to gain inroads to an untapped market.

  4. I said to someone last night that they are clearly setting up someone to win who will move to the CCM market – Jason is my guess. He is a worship leader, exposure to the church scene already, etc.

    The idea popped in my head when I heard about them using the Robbie Seay song but then with all of the other things which you’ve mentioned it’s become pretty obvious.

    Think about it – Kelly is the mainstream pop chick Ruben is the manly R&B guy, (I know he didn’t wint but Clay is the soccer mom “nice boy”), Fantasia is the female R&B chick, Carrie goes country, Taylor was the indie/folk guy but that bombed, Jordin is another mainstream pop/R&B girl. They’re clearly arranging things to spread the winning talent across several genres in the industry to be able to tap a new market every year. This year it’s CCM’s turn.

  5. Ooh… conspiracy theory!

    I didn’t know that about Jason Castro. So I did a quick check and dug up this video of him performing at a church. (After pastor gives the greetings you can see him singing background vocals to another worship song.)

    I’ve noticed a few things with David Archuletta too. Covering a Rebecca St. James cover and another song recently.

    And I’m convinced that Brooke is a celestial being. So….

  6. Interesting choice.

    However American Idol is already marketing to the Christian market.Some who have been released to the Christian market: Rueben Studdard, Clay Aiken, RJ Helton and Mandisa. Mandisa is very popular and hard to keep in stores however if you know anyone who wants 1, 5 or a bunch of RJ send them our way.

  7. Yeah, we were definitely caught off guard by “Shout to the Lord” and found it interesting they said “shepherd” instead of “Jesus”. And we did notice Mariah Carey’s choice in song and Joe thought maybe her choice in a somewhat modest outfit was b/c of her song; funny, though, that Joe realized the outfit she was wearing was close to the same outfit she wore in one of her early music videos (I can’t remember what video now, I was just so blown away that he remembers an outfit she wore years ago and he probably can’t even remember what I wore yesterday!!)

  8. Shane,

    Who would buy Mandisa? We would get lots of requests.

    Who would buy RJ Helton? Apparently no one. He is always in the Gospel Pre-Pack sales. That is why we have 19 copies of that and only 3 copies of Marvin Sapp’s Thristy. I only have those because I got them shelved less than an hour before we closed last night. Sapp will be gone by the weekend.

  9. I suppose. It’s still just weird that they opened with it after closing with it last night.

    From what I’ve heard, the iTunes version that was available for download contained the “Jesus” lyric.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s